Text size
Drive
3 min readText size
Published
Text size
Is there such a thing as too much competition in the car market?
The peak industry body for new car dealers believes so, calling for a cap on vehicle brands sold in Australia amid an influx of challengers.
While acknowledging choice benefits consumers, the Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) says there are also risks in unrestricted expansion, including faster depreciation of vehicles, longer repair times due to a lag in supply of parts and orphaned vehicles when brands disappear.
ADAA chief executive James Voortman says the situation has reached “crisis point” for dealers, who were struggling to sustain the cost of setting up and stocking so many different brands.
The number of car brands on the Australian market has grown from 39 in 2021 to 67 in 2026 and is rising, with numerous newcomers due to launch here in 2027.
According to density research commissioned by the AADA, that is equivalent to about 54 brands for every million vehicles sold. This compares to 19.8 brands per million sales in the UK, 18.9 in Canada and 1.8 in the US.
Voortman called for a “pause on further car brands entering this market,” claiming there were “simply too many manufacturers” operating locally.
“Dealers are facing intense competition, relentless pressure to take more (vehicle) stock and rising business costs,” he said.
"Too often, they are left to absorb the financial consequences of decisions made elsewhere in the supply chain ... At a time when other countries are trying to slow the rate of change and number of brands, Australia is allowing unfettered access.”
But in response, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission reiterated that competition benefits buyers, through greater choice and innovation, better services and lower prices.
“Motor vehicle manufacturers and importers, existing and new entrants, must comply with the Australian Consumer Law consumer guarantees obligations,” an ACCC spokesperson said.
“(These) include a guarantee that spare parts and repair facilities are made reasonably available, unless the business explicitly notifies consumers otherwise before purchase.”
The ACCC supported strengthening the laws with civil penalties for businesses that fail to meet the consumer guarantees and don't provide a remedy, when legally required to do so. These should also apply when manufacturer don’t reimburse suppliers who provide remedies to consumers that the manufacturer is responsible for.
Voortman said that the July to September quarter had delivered the industry’s first negative profit result since the global financial crisis.
“Pushing excessive stock onto dealers is fuelling a race to the bottom. Aggressive discounting erodes margins and devalues vehicles while dealers carry the financing costs and risk of unsold vehicles,” he said.
“Strong headline vehicle sales can conceal serious financial distress at the businesses making those sales. Dealers cannot keep absorbing higher costs, lower margins and greater stock risk indefinitely.”
Unlike many mature car markets, Australia no longer has meaningful import tariffs on vehicles, having long levelled out at five per cent for countries not part of a free trade agreement.
Vehicles from countries that do have an FTA with Australia – including China, Thailand, Japan, South Korea and the United States – do not have to pay any import duty.
In contrast, up until the 1980s, the tariff on fully imported vehicles was at nearly 60 per cent, but gradually dropped by 2.5 per cent annually, to where it is today. And with the end of full-line vehicle manufacturing at the end of 2017, there has been lobbying to scrap tariffs altogether.
Barring Cupra, which is an offshoot of Volkswagen’s Spanish arm, SEAT, independent carmaker Ineos and the return of GM’s century plus marques GMC and Cadillac, all the additional car brands this decade have come from China.
At least 12 have arrived since 2024, with a further dozen confirmed before the end of next year. As a result, AADA estimates that there could be upwards of 75 brands operating in Australia by early 2030s.